Death Masks by Jim Butcher
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
Although this book loosely follows the formula of the preceding Dresden Files stories, this instalment packs a political punch and is a worthy follow-up to the drama of Summer Knight. This time, we’re introduced to a darker side of magic that makes the sidhe we encountered previously look like childsplay.
Fortunately, we’re also introduced to a host of new characters and its the relationship Dresden builds with these (and the old favourites, naturally!) that really makes this book work. This gives Dresden’s personality the time to shine and really brings more to his character other than the self-pitying, misogynistic smart-ass side we’ve seen too many times at this point. Though a lot of that still exists, the well-needed added depth to Dresden is enough to keep the reader hooked as we follow him through his barmy world of wizarding adventures.
Death Masks takes quite a while to really get going thanks to a lengthy intro about the White Council which initially put me off the book despite Dresden’s cringey comic relief comments. Still, the book more than makes up for this with its crazy action scenes that build a prepackaged action movie into your imagination. Although by this point these are cliché to the point of cringeworthy, they’re still a worthwhile guilty pleasure that seamlessly works with the plot.
All in all, the Dresden Files has came along way by this point from the cheesy first three instalments and is now turning out to be a pretty exciting, light-hearted series with enough dollops of suspense and darkness to hold interest.
View all my reviews
Summer Knight by Jim Butcher
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
Finally an instalment in the Dresden Files series that I can confidently give a 5 star rating to!
Throughout my progress on the series so far I’ve met many reviewers saying ‘it gets good around book 3/4/5/6’ (the number varies massively depending on who you ask), and at long last I’ve found where in the series that moment happens for me and it’s here, right with this book which fortunately for me, is almost unrecognisable from the confusion and incoherence that was Grave Peril.
So why such a big turnaround?
First of all, Harry Dresden gets some long-awaited character development beyond the overly done funny-underdog-saves-the-day-by-a-hair’s-breadth-and-is-at-the-brink-of-death-two-dozen-times (phew!) formula that Jim Butcher keeps on winging out for him. Now we’re treated to only a little of self-pitying instead of being swamped by it and this alone does great things for Dresden’s likeability. We’re also introduced to much stronger and more interesting characters than Butcher has ever given us in the past and seeing Harry’s reactions to these gives a solid plus in his direction. It’s nice as well to see some old faces in the book – their personalities really took on a realistic shape thanks to the intricacy of the plot (more on that later).
Secondly, the humour in the books is either improving greatly or I’ve finally became used to it! It took some time to see it as anything other than cliché and cheesy action-hero lines but in Summer Knight Butcher finally takes the humour a little further and pulls it off to great effect.
Thirdly, the plot! Wow did this book get intricate! A far-cry away from the previously simplistic plots of figuring out the bad guy and taking said bad-guy down via several drawn out action scenes (view spoiler), Summer Knight’s plot takes on a much more ambitious storyline and manages to make it work throughout the entire book. I must admit, I was a little lost-off around 200 pages towards the end but I soon managed to pick up on what was going on thanks to brilliant pacing and plot development.
Last but not least…
How much more incredible does the magical world get in this book? You need to read it to believe it. I didn’t think the series would ever go beyond anything more than ‘whodunit’ with a pinch of magic thrown in for variety but instead, it becomes much much more.
Finally this series is starting to live up to the hype that surrounds it by giving us a glimpse of where Jim Butcher’s world-building talent lies. I can’t wait to move onto to Death Masks and see what more adventures Harry Dresden has in store for us!
View all my reviews